# Gingerbread and Conscience

By T Rubens, December 12, 2022
Source: https://thehonestmajority.org/stories/gingerbread-and-conscience

Kitty sits with her feet swinging short of the floor, her large striped socks hanging loose around the toes. Her breaths are heavy, and her cheeks are flushed pink like unripe plums. She clasps a coloured pencil in her hand, absorbed in the illogical mixture of capitals and lower-case lettering that constitutes her Christmas list. Kitty is only supposed to ask for one thing this year because of the boiler. She’s not sure quite why the boiler gets her presents, but that’s the rule and so she is having to think very hard, tongue pressed firmly over her lower lip.

Last year Kitty received a whole stocking full of all sorts of presents, like spherical chocolates in coloured foil, a wooden snake that could slither back and forth, a set of astronaut stickers, a pair of gloves with bobbles on the knuckles, and tangerines that were sweet and plump. But Kitty’s favourite present had been a beautiful fairy tale storybook with a hard, shiny cover and lovely big illustrations on every single page and words that curled at the edges because they were so full of magic. Her hands were too small to hold all the pages at once, so she had laid the book over her lap and stroked her fingertips over the gossamer wings of the woodland fairies and the velvet cloak of the prince riding across the drawbridge.

Kitty considers asking for a new coat; her coat is a little too small and a little too thin and the winds seem colder and meaner this winter. But a coat has none of the magic of a fairy tale storybook. Of course, a wonderful furry coat like those in the Narnia wardrobe would certainly be a splendid choice, but Kitty’s mother has said that the present must be *economical*, which means it needs to cost less than fifteen pounds. A very fine fur coat will probably be a little more than that, Kitty decides.

Kitty swaps her blue pencil for a green one and chews the skin of her thumb. Suddenly, a clever idea rises in her mind with all the brilliance of the dawn sun: Father Christmas doesn’t necessarily know about the one-present-rule.

Kitty takes a new piece of paper and restarts her letter. After further contemplation, she asks for a skipping rope with purple handles and for an illustrated book about the rainforest that she saw in the bookshop window on the high street.

*I am allowed two presents this year,* she adds at the bottom, *because I have been good.*

Kitty signs the letter and seals it in an envelope upon which she writes Mr S. CLAUS in her very neatest print. She takes the letter into the hall and puts it on the side table for her mother to post in the afternoon, then she returns to the kitchen and takes a gingerbread man from the chequered biscuit tin.

As the sweetness and spice dissolves on her tongue, Kitty looks out of the window. The air is bright with cold and the leaves of the paperwhites in the window box are crisp with frost. Father Christmas lives in the North Pole, which must be much colder than London, since there is snow there even in summertime. Kitty wonders if Father Christmas has enough warmth to sleep at night, when it is even colder. An unease takes root in her stomach; initially, she hopes that the tight knots might be the fault of the gingerbread man, but as she licks the remains of the biscuit from between her teeth, it becomes increasingly obvious that the problem is one of conscience, rather than digestion.

Kitty tiptoes back into the hall to retrieve the letter, only to find her mother is already there holding the envelope in her pale hands. She is smiling a sad sort of smile and jumps when Kitty pulls softly on her cardigan sleeve.

“I need to write a new letter,” Kitty says, blushing and lowering her gaze. Her mother strokes her hair and asks why. Kitty bites her lip, then tells her mother about the lie that sits inside the envelope, her face alight with shame. “I shouldn’t have asked for two presents,” she says, “it wasn’t honest.”

Kitty’s mother looks at her daughter for a long time without saying anything. Her green eyes are both dusty and sharp at the same time, and you can see the shadows where her skull presses against her skin. Kitty wonders how she will be punished. It dawns on her that she may now receive no presents at all, but then her mother reaches into her pocket, takes out her purse and fishes around until she finds a second-class stamp. She peels it free, licks it twice, and pastes it neatly onto the corner of the envelope.

“We can post it this afternoon,” Kitty’s mother says.

“But I told a lie,” Kitty whispers, swallowing a sob. “I’ll get coal.”

“Coal wouldn’t be the worst gift to receive this year,” Kitty’s mother laughs. Kitty isn’t sure she understands the joke. She screws up her face in an attempt not to cry, and her mother kneels and takes her hands. “You told the truth eventually, Kitty, and that’s what counts. This Christmas won’t be quite like last year, but Father Christmas is magic, after all. That’s the special thing about him. He’ll work something out.” She kisses the girl softly on the tip of her nose and brushes a strand of her from her teary eyes. “Now go and do your homework.”

Kitty sniffs, gives a weak smile, then scampers off into the kitchen. Her mother takes a long breath and gets to her feet. She picks at a hole in her cardigan and pulls it tighter around her frame, before walking slowly to the thermometer and turning the dial down another degree.
