I was at dinner with my cousin a few years ago, in a suburb about an hour’s drive to the north of Washington DC. Her and her husband, another couple and I were all sitting out on the terrace of her condo, crunching crackers through a pleasantly dwindling evening. I was visiting for the week; I hadn’t seen my cousin in some time, and it was my first time meeting the other couple. They were all about twenty years older to me, they had young children, whereas I was a few years out of college and steaming it up in the city. Little was spoken, or so I felt. Politeness, why did we lean on politeness? There were so many threads weaving through every day of mine - collapsing and colliding threads of flagrant loves and heartache. It was a time of flux, where my friends were confessing ever-deeper envies and secret ambitions to each other, unlocking dusty casks of psyche; all the time more and more possibilities for us being together, communicating, relating, were resolving. Here. Why did we all sit as if stuffed and move only our mouths, occasionally our hands to the cheese plate? I stared off into the dimly lit trees on the other side of the road.
When the woman in the couple asked me what I was thinking about, I decided to respond with authenticity, the lacking ingredient at dinner (sorry), a play in return for an honest response that would get at some deeper level of connection between us, that would bring out what was unsaid, her choice of earrings, his stillness, the way she looked at him when he suggested moving back to Nepal. I am thinking about a young man back in New York, I said, his name is Brian and he builds educational VR scenes and then I detailed out our relationship together, a passion cut short by his impending cross-country move back to San Francisco. I didn’t speak very long, I was watching their responses. The table was silent for a moment. The men looked somewhat stern, I think to cover their confusion. The woman in the couple nodded, eyes getting big. I think she asked how we met. Then, the group adjusted, moving on, back to politeness.
[Later, the man in the couple took me aside and said. Be careful how you act. Because other people will start to act like you.]
Honesty is the unnerving option, honesty often comes as a surprise. There is a big murky space between the intention with which we set out and the many-layered views through which an action can be perceived. A speaker may not desire to communicate through that murky space, sending ping in the dark, and a listener may prefer the clearer, easier landscape of polite communication. The line between these divergent needs can often only be discovered in the course of the conversation itself. But if you only speak, you will only learn. Speak, to excavate the line, and to challenge it.

