“They didn’t even touch the cash register?”
I’m sitting across the desk from Detective Gardenia of the Lighthouse Point, Florida police department.
The detective and I are having this little chat this afternoon because last night, while working at the Majik Market convenience store, I was robbed.
I had only been on less than an hour of my 6pm-6am shift, and, to add insult to injury, it was the night of the Super Bowl!
During a futile effort to tune in the game amidst the static of an old AM radio, two guys came up to the counter. One asked me who was winning the Super Bowl, and then, before I could say anything, they both leapt over the counter, knocking over all the assorted paraphernalia stacked there.
The first one had a gun which he held to my head as he ordered me to face the wall with my hands up.
“Don’t talk and don’t move!” he shouted, while watching his partner go straight for the drop safe in the floor under the ratty carpet.
The drop safe, usually for money order receipts, was supposed to be locked, but the clerks, myself included, felt it was too much trouble to dial the 3-digit combination each time we had to make a cash drop. It remained unlocked almost always. Such was money drop technology in 1981.
More importantly, the clerk whose shift was ending, was supposed to take the cash, put it in a bank deposit bag, and bring it to the bank to deposit.
Three days out of five the clerk I relieved was my wife Pat, who invariably would ask me to “take mine when you take yours,” what difference does it make?”
Every time right up until this one it did not make any difference.
The thief reached under the carpet, pulled up the top of the unlocked drop safe, grabbed the deposit bag, and the two of them leapt back over the counter and out the door.
Without ever touching the cash register.
“So, Dave,” the detective continued, “these guys knew where the floor safe was, and they knew it would be unlocked with a full deposit bag in there. The full deposit bag your wife was supposed to bring to the bank at the end of her shift. That sort of explains why they knew there was no use messing with the cash register. But how did they know all that? Get you a coffee?”
“Sure, thanks. Okay, I admit, it looks bad.”
“Oh, you got that right. Cream and sugar?”
“Sure. Well, they knew because, obviously, they had cased the store and saw that clerks left the safe unlocked when they put cash from money order sales in there, and also that sometimes clerks didn’t take the cash deposit bag with them when their shift ended. And, they hit me at the start of my shift, just the minimum in the register, when the Super Bowl is on so it’s likely not to be crowded.”
The detective puffed on a cigar, giving me the most accusatory stare, I could ever remember anyone giving me since, well, ever.
“Well Dave, that’s one version, I guess. That would make these guys quite the criminal geniuses, wouldn’t it?”
I started to interrupt but he cut me off with,
“But here’s my version, and I’ve seen it happen this way a lot more times. Young people come down to Florida from up north, looking for warm weather and parties, the beach, sure, why not, right? But they find they blow through their savings pretty quick and then they find they don’t have the means to make a good living. So, they get some low-paying job like convenience store clerk. People buy money orders, they see cash coming in, a lot more than they are making per hour. You see where I’m going with this? They have a buddy or two come in and “rob” them, they all meet up later and split the take.”
“That’s not what happened,” I said, but his tone was so chilling I began to fear honesty alone might not get me out of this. He went on,
“So, here’s the thing, Dave. Come clean now, just own up to the fake robbery, return the money, and I can work with you, I can smooth things out, you’re young, it’s a first offense…”
“Look,” I said, “not locking the safe, not making the deposit, yes, we did that, but…”
He quickly cut me off ignoring what I’d said, “But…if the investigation goes forward and you are proven guilty, well…all bets are off, you’re looking at felony larceny charges. So, what’s it gonna be, Dave?”
Of course, I didn’t take any “deal,” for an uncommitted crime. I did have to agree to a polygraph, the supposed scientific last word in honesty. I passed. And, I did not lose my job, but I did quit not too long afterwards, taking with me the lesson that however strong the honest truth may live within you, be too careless about your circumstances, and the world will try hard to make you doubt it.

