My mother took for granted that a child cowed into compliance would never break the law, but when I was ten,I almost did just that in order to please her. Since going back to work, she’d become so irritable, I was desperate to make things right again.
It was a Sunday in May, one month before the neighbors at our summer camp were due to return, when I spied the green bottle I’d pulled from the lakebed nine months earlier. It was gathering dust in Mrs. Wellborn’s shed, not looking any better than when I’d given it to her. She’d just adored its hexagonal shape and lopsided rim, and was sure she could clean the mud out with sand, so I said if she liked it so much, she could have it. She’d asked cautiously if my mother might not want it, but I couldn’t picture her going to such pains for some old rubbish, as she would surely call it, and then do what with it?
I was wrong. I never knew her to be jealous before I mentioned it. Without even having seen the thing, she cried over its loss, ranting and putting words in my mouth like I didn’t think she was good enough for such things and calling Mrs. Wellborn that rich snob.
Mrs. Wellborn was different from the other mothers I knew, it was true. Her hair was more stylish. Her clothes looked straight out of an L.L. Bean catalog. She served her family crustless sandwiches for lunch, on cloth napkins.
Maybe my mother was just tired that day, but I couldn’t help feeling she was still angry, and not just about the bottle. That year, she slapped me for the first time when I accidentally broke a ceramic figurine her mother had made. She called me careless and uncaring—words that seemed not only untrue but paradoxical. We both cared too much.
Mrs. Wellborn didn’t want or need that bottle. She could buy any antique she wanted, and I needed this one back. My mother wouldn’t have to know where it came from. I could maybe pick the lock, as I once heard someone in a movie explain how, and Mrs. Wellborn would never notice anything amiss. No one was around to see.
I pressed my ear to the dial and turned it, listening for tumblers, but all I heard was a squeak. The door was already cracked open, and the hinges looked weak. Maybe if I just helped them break. I wedged a stick between it and the rotting door jamb, and jiggled it to see what would happen. When the rusty screws popped out a quarter inch, my underarms went all prickly. I toggled the stick slower and one screw fell out, but the other held fast, the only thing between me and that which haunted me.
I imagined my mother opening her gift on Mother’s Day and asking where I got such a unique old bottle. I pictured myself stammering a lie and her look of horrified disappointment when she realized what I’d done, as she surely would. She knew everything. I skulked away, a failed daughter and failed thief. I couldn’t even bear to be an Indian giver, which was how I’d gotten in this fix in the first place. What I was, was a coward.
When the Wellborn family returned in June, they didn’t mention anything out of order, and I didn’t ask. But I also didn’t come around to play with their little boy as often as I used to.

