The first time our oldest child lied to us, my husband and I were appalled. We thought that was the worst thing he could do. After all, we never lied to our parents. Did we?
Since we’ve both studied philosophy, we should have known better. Truth is not an easy concept. Philosophers, in fact, talk endlessly about what knowledge and truth mean. Usually, they agree that knowledge is something like justified, true belief. Seems simple enough, but that turns out to be a problematic definition. What does it mean to be justified in believing something? Not everyone agrees on what sufficient evidence consists of. A lot of misunderstandings about the limits of science involve the expectation of irrefutable evidence to back up a theory. Other people go the other way and simply search for evidence that supports or seems to support something they already believe. That’s how creationists and flat-earthers manage to hold onto their beliefs. Anything that contradicts their theories is discounted, ignored, or best yet, incorporated into the theory in some convoluted way, like how creationists explain dinosaur bones as God’s cosmic joke.
We can also be perfectly justified in believing something and yet, at the same time, be horribly wrong. If the clock, which I believe is working, tells me it’s noon, I’ll think that’s the correct time. But if the clock is in fact, broken, and it’s not noon, I’ll be wrong.
What about people who believe something true by pure chance? For example, maybe the clock is broken, and I don’t know it. However, the hands are stuck at noon, and I happen to look at it at when it’s actually exactly noon. I am right, but am I justified? Does it matter? (This kind of epistemological problem is attributed to the philosopher Edmund Gettier.)
Belief itself is another huge problem that philosophers argue about. What does it really mean to believe something? It seems obvious that our actions reflect our beliefs (if I believe the floor is lava, I won’t step on it), but it doesn’t always work that way. People might say they believe one thing, but then act in a way completely contrary to that claim. How often do they say that they don’t believe in luck and then wear their special T-shirt so the team will win? How many times have you heard someone claim to be a survivalist who can thrive in any conditions and then talk about how they need top quality health care?
The older I get, the more I think we must lie to ourselves about what we really believe and how the world actually is in order to survive. The amount of pain, terror, and suffering on Earth is beyond anything we can endure or even imagine. If we allow ourselves to actually see, admit, or even acknowledge it, we’ll collapse into a never-ending fetal position of despair. We have to tell ourselves that it isn’t happening or at the very least that we can’t do anything about it. In fact, each of us probably could reduce the suffering in the world by one tiny fraction if we devoted our entire lives to it, giving up any dreams, ambitions, and desires of our own. But that’s too depressing to contemplate, as well as futile, so most of us don’t.
The twelve-step admonition that we should only try to change the things we can and accept the things we can’t isn’t terribly helpful either. Knowing what we are capable of changing or even what we’re capable of at all isn’t any easier than obtaining any other knowledge. I might be technically capable of gardening, but in reality, I know that I’ll quickly lose interest and every plant under my care will die. There is logical possibility (anything that avoids a contradiction), metaphysical possibility (anything that jives with the laws of physics), and then temperamental possibility (I made this one up, but basically it means what our personality can handle). Usually, we don’t know what we’re capable of until we try, but, let’s face it, there are things we aren’t even temperamentally able to try. I might be capable of skydiving, but I’m never going to find out.
I’m not judging people for any of this because I’m just as guilty of all of it as anyone else. So, when I think about that small child lying to me, it doesn’t seem so bad now. We all have to learn what the truth is, how close we can get to it, and how much of it we can endure. It’s understandable that a five-year-old kid might not have a handle on it yet.
I suppose all I really have to say about it is that we can’t expect anyone to do anything they aren’t capable of, including little children, conspiracy theorists, “normal” people, and, perhaps most importantly, ourselves. If we remind ourselves of that, we’ll be happier, or at least less unhappy with the current state of Earth. As most philosophers will tell you, happiness isn’t what it’s all about, but a base level of contentment, or at least the absence of total despair, is necessary for survival. And if we don’t survive, we can’t do the little good we are capable of in the world. It may not make a huge amount of difference, but it’s all we have. As my kids’ teachers say, “A little is enough for me.”

