Stories

That Which I Should Have Said

By Elizabeth Mayhew

Image submitted with the story "That Which I Should Have Said"

What meaning truly lies behind a handful of recurring words? What actually can be found within a stare? Thinking back on this notion now its funny, I realize at that particular point in time, was the one point at which I might have elected to do something greatly different from what I actually did.

When I was small, and the earth melted around me like children mixing paints to make new ones I say the world in a metaphorical red and gray. I think you get a muted red with those colours. This was in Northwestern Ontario. My father was a professor to be more specific a writer, but he wouldn’t give himself that title even though that was all he ever did or wanted to do. He was friends (if you can say he had friends, his books were his friends) with a writer who was friends with another writer who was undoubtedly friends with an even more famous writer then the last. I read his book. The most famous writer of my dad’s friend’s friend. His forte radical evil in soul and society. Somehow this book was different to me. Mostly because I actually wanted to read it (because I thought I could say I read a book by someone I knew), secondly, he said it was okay to be sinful. (Later I found out that meant “bad” when I looked it up in the dictionary) But that’s basically what he said but in like 50 000 more words. Words at that time I had no way of possibly understanding. But I do remember one “Faith”. In retrospect, its easy to see how I should’ve known better, reading a book pertaining to the concept of morals, radical sin, and one’s soul at the age of twelve. At the very least I should have known something was constructively different about this particular book. Something about the concept of one’s morals at the age of twelve struck a chord with me. How they’re viewed as a social phenomenon something to be abhorred. (Well, I didn’t think exactly those words, because you know I was like twelve, but you get the idea) People often think that morals like most stories have a beginning, middle and end or for morals standard right or wrong and I mean occasionally they do. But that structure is only as true as the person telling the story.

Funnily enough, after going to the library to finish up reading the book by the friends, friend’s writer I went home. Turned the key into the lock like always with a click at the end when it turns. I heard something coming from my parent’s room, I knew my dad wasn’t home. I supposed at the time standing in the dimly lit hall I should have told my dad, maybe it would have saved us a lot of time, lies, and secrecy later but I didn’t. Maybe the book on morals affected me I don’t know, maybe I’m trying to use that as an excuse, all I really know is that I didn’t tell my dad what I heard, I didn’t go into the room to check what the sound was, and I didn’t lock the door on the way out. (The door wasn’t important, but it seemed like a huge thing at the time because I got yelled at for it only hours later) All I know and what’s truly important is that I didn’t tell my dad what I heard and that I was stuck with a sense of horror that I just listened to something I wasn’t supposed to hear. Not at all unlike the horror, you feel when you accidentally call your teacher mom or when find out you have no idea who is flying the plane you’re now sitting on. The feeling sits in your gut, it churns over and over, and you realize you made a mistake only after you comprehend there’s nothing you can do.

` Like most people you don’t wake up and your like “Hey Dad I think Moms having an affair” most don’t wake up and know their moms having an affair. But I did. In 2014 surrounded by magazines spitting nonstop gossip on Brittney spears, Beyonce and Miley Cyrus I could remember looking at these iconic pop icons and thinking Thirty-two the age Brittney was turning that year. But more than it just being Brittney’s birthday the number thirty-two also reminded me of the numbers forty-four and fifty. All numbers in astounding clarity of crisp times new roman font in specifically in size 12. Thirty-Two the age my mom had me and my sister. Forty-four the age my mom started her affair. Fifty that age she would finally tell my dad in her own words that never included the words “I’m sorry.” I mean she could have said it to make my father feel better or maybe she felt she owed him more comfort than the word “sorry” could ever provide him. Possibly I’m making excuses for my mother’s behavior because I still love her. But I’m trying not to sit here pretending that I know everything about inherent adultery and sin because I don’t. But that understanding just makes me feel worse.

You’re probably reading this thinking “this bitch is a liar” and I mean yes, I might be a liar, having not told my dad till years later but at least I’m a losing liar right. Most people want to see the monster in tragedy be slayed whether that be my mother for adultery, or me for withholding the truth. And I mean me, and my mom did lose. It reeked of deception, it performed like a tragedy, and sang a symphony of flight and fall.

I think that notion is rather charming. How choices convict, compel and create us to decisions. But so is life. Living thirty-two, forty-four, and fifty plane crashes at a time.

← All stories

Do your best

If you do your best to be honest with yourself and others, you are helping to make The Honest Majority.

Advance Honesty