My divorce became final more than a decade years ago. I don’t think about it often.
Occasionally, though, its insistence on being remembered slaps me in the face. It’s uncomfortable. It’s hard.
This last time, I was reminded of my first marriage as I stood in the garage of my parents’ house—a sprawling ranch in eastern Indiana. I was lit up inside because my husband and my half-brother were talking bikes—which saddles (a fancy word for seats) were best for long rides.
As they spoke, I wandered over to the tool bench. My father keeps a meticulous garage. Bob Villa would drool. Every tool is in place. Every box is labeled.
My eyes landed on a box labeled, “Colleen’s Good China.”
The good china. My good china.
I remembered standing with my mother in a Bed Bath & Beyond, staring out at a sea of dishes. Pure white, eggshell, cream. Beautiful.
And expensive. I remembered raising my eyebrow at the price tags.
But my mother told me people expected me to register for good china. They wanted to buy this for me and my first husband.
Evidently, we needed good china in order to entertain.
I was to become part of a married couple who invited guests to dinner.
This was the doorway to my new life.
All I needed to do was step in.
I picked up a box: a place setting complete with a dinner plate, a salad plate, a coffee cup, a dessert plate. It was $50. It was pretty, though, with silver borders: a pattern of long, thin, wavy lines that made hearts and intricate loops. I realized my mother and I were supposed to be bonding. I wanted to make her happy. I wanted to do all the right things to become a real adult.
I raised my black scanning gun over the barcode and pressed my finger on the trigger, over and over again, until the quantity reached a dozen.
Two years later, I was deeply unhappy and staring at what looked like decades of depression and emptiness in that house, in that marriage. It’s possible we could have gone to therapy and taken other steps to salvage our marriage, but the end truth is I wasn’t interested in that. I left him.
It took him a while to come around to it, to see it was the right thing to do: we were young, we didn’t have children, we both had college degrees and good friends and families, jobs that paid well. It was going to be all right if we split.
All those wedding gifts needed to be divided: the wine cooler, the bread maker, the nice toaster, the fruit bowl, the pots, the pans, the fluffy towels, the high thread count sheets.
Because the divorce was my idea, I left him as much as I could. I took my old bed from college, my books, my clothes. I made a lot of trips to Target those first few months on my own to fill in all the gaps with clearance household wares.
I boxed up the good china and took that, too. I figured he didn’t want it.
One night alone in my new apartment, feeling sorry for myself for being 26 and divorced, I heated up some pasta in the microwave using the good china.
You know what happens next.
Within seconds of hitting the start button, an eerie popping sound hit my ears. I looked through the translucent door to see sparks flying from the beautiful silver border: a fireworks display happening right before my eyes.
I yanked open the microwave door quickly.
You can’t microwave good china.
Any good hostess would know that. But I wasn’t a good hostess, was I?
The plate didn’t appear damaged, but I felt like an even bigger failure. The plate now represented all the hopes my mother had for me and my first marriage—all the things I think she thought she was passing on. She had a long and loving marriage with my father. She’d helped me pick out the right dishes. That plate made me confront how deeply I’d disappointed her—how starkly her wisdom was wasted on me. It seemed all I knew was how to damage beautiful things. Another minute in that microwave and I would have ruined that plate forever.
Scraping my room-temperature lasagna onto a paper plate, I considered how useless my good china was. It didn’t fit me. It didn’t fit the life I was trying to find. It was gorgeous, but who cared?
Those plates were doomed for destruction if they stayed with me—just as I felt I was doomed if I’d stayed married—at 25—to a man at the time, I had come to almost hate.
I put the china back into its box and bought a set of white dishes perfect for everyday use at Target. I gave the good china to my mother. I sensed that it still meant something to her, even though to me, it was baggage. I knew she only wanted me to be happily married. So did everyone who bought us a place setting.
I didn’t lose that dream for myself.
Sometimes I wonder if my mother is waiting for me to say I want it back.
I wonder if she thinks I’ll grow into it, now that I’ve settled down with a sweet and wonderful man with whom I share a loving partnership. Together, he and I have raised two babies into playful children who sometimes slam their silverware onto those everyday white plates I bought so long ago just to hear that satisfying clanking.
I wonder if she’s waiting for me to say I am ready to take on the good china.
But I don’t think it’s really for me.

