# Three Truths and the Chord

By Greg Beatty, November 17, 2022
Source: https://thehonestmajority.org/stories/three-truths-and-the-chord

Songwriter Harlan Howard once said that country music is “three chords and the truth.” He should know: the man wrote more than 4000 songs, including “I Fall to Pieces,” one of my all-time favorites. Well, I’d like to flip that on its head, and talk about three truths and the chord that runs between them. It might still end up sounding like a country song in the end, though.

I come from a religious family. Every Sunday we attended a Methodist church filled with nice if sometimes boring people. My mom’s faith, though, was fiercer and more intense. She was drawn to less mainstream expressions of belief, and fell (or dove) down the evangelical rabbit hole of those who anticipated the Rapture, when all true Christians would be taken up to heaven, leaving the earth to the sinners. Hal Lindsey books like *The Late Great Planet Earth* were scattered around the house. My mother was ready for the End Times, and that meant the rest of us had to be too. During one period she stockpiled food against the possibility that we’d be left behind. I still remember looking for toilet paper one day, and sending canned goods tumbling to the bathroom floor.

Alternately bored and terrified by religion, I found my faith withering. After months of restless impatience, I finally spoke up, sharing my first truth in a moment of early teen rebellion. I told my mom I didn’t want to go to church anymore.

This was the first time I really remember standing up for myself, and it failed about as completely as something can fail. In addition to having intense faith, my mom has a quick and violent temper. Which she lost. With me. “So long as you live in this house, you will go to church!” I heard it as an ultimatum: go to church or get out.

I caved completely. I never brought it up again, and I attended church every week until I left for college, year after year of faithless, resentful, dishonesty. (Lest you think I overreacted to a single moment, consider this. Years later my mom went through a period in which she was babysitting several kids, a genuinely kind act to help two other families going through difficulties. She had them ten to twelve hours a day, seven days a week. When my dad, who was the only one of my parents employed at the time, asked to have one evening a week without kids, so he could rest, my mom answered, “Fine. I’ll move out.)

Besides distancing me for decades from any form of faith or spirit, this failed attempt to live my truth had many other side effects. One of these was an almost instinctive fear of being honest in intimate relationships. Not about everything: I could voice movie preferences and share food choices with the best of them. (“No! *The Princess Bride* and egg rolls.”) But when I sensed that something was important to a woman I cared about, I caved. Over and over and over again. This led, once again, to times of restless frustration, and the belief that I could not be myself in a relationship. It also led me to find women who wanted a relationship by their rules and lights. There were always reasons, and they were always reasonable reasons: women with kids had to protect them, you know? Or they had traumas or job offers or callings. There was always something that required them to define the relationship. And me to accept those definitions.

But while you, well, I, can live a lie for a long time, it turns out I can’t live one forever. When I finally did get married, I was the supportive husband for years, paying for everything while she returned to school and putting my own dreams on hold. The marriage looked good from the outside, and I looked good in the role of supportive husband.

But at some point, the pressure to speak up grew. With it grew the fear that speaking up would end the relationship, a fear that was a certainty: if I am honest on things that matter, she’ll leave me. I could hear that echoing in my head, in my heart. But here’s the other thing, the second truth: if you— if I— don’t speak up, then it’s not really me in the relationship. And keeping quiet and accepting someone else’s reality isn’t being good and supportive. It’s being a coward. And the marriage grows hollow on the vine like a rotten gourd, no matter how pleasant it looks like from the outside.

And so came the third truth, the time I finally said no. I didn’t say it loudly. I didn’t say it suddenly. I didn’t withdraw my support or make any demands on my then-wife. I just, finally, said I didn’t want to move to another state as she had suddenly requested, didn’t want to move far away from all family and everyone and everything I knew. I wasn’t opposed to starting over, but we’d both already done that. I didn’t want to go.

So I spoke up, knowing that on one hand I was right. She did leave me when I stopped saying yes to everything she wanted. It wasn’t immediate, but it was inevitable. But on the other hand, I was right to speak up, because I was dying. It wasn’t me she didn’t love because I wasn’t me with her.

And now I’m alone, a divorced man with an ex 500 miles away, but quietly happy, humming my own little country song as I find out who I really am. Because I told the truth, and I didn’t fall to pieces. Even if my lie did.

THE END
