Stories

To Be What You Are

By Emily Schoeller

Image submitted with the story "To Be What You Are"

I wasn't as off as they said. Perhaps the cues I missed caused others to judge, and maybe the looks I gave did not come across as what I intended-- but I was not as off as they believed. You? You were about as ideal as they had imagined me to be. You laughed without the prompt of the sound already echoing through the air, and your grin was the first to light up the room. My mimicry could do you no shame, as I was nothing more than a foul illusion.

The gears in my head were turning: a truth I truly stand behind. I made desperate grasps at the connotations that should be natural, yet they were but plastic fillings through the gaps in my mind. Was I envious? No, that couldn’t be it. I didn't want to be you even if you were what I wanted to be. So, no, it could not be envy. It was an emotion that ran much deeper yet stood right at the surface of my heart. I yearned for the understanding of people, the way your face revealed what was meant to be thought, but I wanted nothing more than the mechanics.

Your eyes showed more than I could comprehend-- more than I wanted to feel. Ignorance was blissful in my shallow heart, and the rhythmic doubt was better reserved for others. Granted, I was not quite immune. No matter the hard shell they believed me to have, my skin was just as brittle as yours. You were blemished with work, hardships I did not want to know, yet you moved with the smoothness of a settled stream. How have you moved past violent storms to remain calm? Did it not bother you, or was I wrong? Maybe you were not peaceful water but instead an iceberg: frozen and running deeper than I could ever imagine.

Worst of all, you were forgiving. No matter the flaws in my movements, you fixed me with a look of understanding. How did you know what I meant? How did your face morph to reveal what I could not? Were there muscles I lacked, perceptions I missed, abilities I was not deserving of? I was a bad student of your teachings; the silent lessons fell on deaf ears. We were not the same, as your eyebrows furrowed to easily express your sympathy for our peers, for me.

So you forgive me, I know you do. Your expressions seep seamlessly into mine-- a new face for me to wear. Your voice echoes through my mind in a ringing plea, so I forgive you for you. The gold in your veins seeping into the concrete as I carved with the delicacy of Michaelangelo, I begin the absolution before I receive your gifts.

As your grip weakened on my arms, you forgive me. The bruises from your aggression begin the process of turning the mauve you often adorned, and you forgive me. Though the silence cannot voice your forgiveness, the crumpled expression you once had, that now belongs to me, offers such. I wear what you had once been blessed with as the offering of your indulgence to the actions my past self-inflicted.

I forgive myself, wearing your marred skin with the understanding that this is all that I had been missing. Yet, as I weep, the tears are leaking from my eyes, not yours. Would you have cried if you had done this to me? I’m not quite sure I would have been forgiving, but I refuse to believe I could see you for anything but the angel you were.

Now you will stay with me, your pardon will guide me forth, and soon I will be what you were. The first light in the room, the sweet laughter that put sirens to shame, and I would be forgiving. Thank you. I forgive you.

← All stories

Do your best

If you do your best to be honest with yourself and others, you are helping to make The Honest Majority.

Advance Honesty