Stories

Turning Into My Mother

By Madeleine McDonald

Image submitted with the story "Turning Into My Mother"

The inescapable truth is that I have turned into my mother.

As a teenager, that was never meant to happen. With the unthinking cruelty of youth, my brother and I used to mutter that what she needed was a job to keep her out of our hair. She was a stay-at-home mum and, as we saw it, she was under-employed, channelling considerable energy into her attempts to run our lives.

We both took her services for granted. It never occurred to me she would not down tools to help me with maths homework or to unpick a zip I had sewn in wrong. Her help was freely given, albeit underpinned by the conviction she knew best.

All my adult life, I have struggled to resist the fatal tendency to step in and give others the benefit of my advice. When one early boyfriend commented that I was exactly like Mum in that respect, I never forgave him.

If only I could go back and apologise.

I never realised how much work she did behind the scenes. Growing up, I truly thought she had made a deliberate choice to be a stay-at-home mother, a situation I intended to avoid.

Until I read Betty Friedan and Gloria Steinem in my twenties, I was oblivious to the frustration of a generation of women who had done their bit in the war, from driving tractors to code-breaking. My generation fought for equal pay, and thereafter took it for granted. In Mum’s time, women were herded back to the kitchen sink when their menfolk returned from the war.

Dad, lovely man that he was, would have crawled over broken glass rather than let his wife take a job. Male pride was at stake. Mum, intellectually curbed, with zero interest in housework, cooking or hygiene, poured an abundance of energy into gardening—and dispensing unsolicited advice to all and sundry.

Whatever her private thoughts, she appeared relaxed about physical risk, something I only understood when I became a parent myself. Even when my brother almost decapitated me by walking under the clothes line with me standing on his shoulders, she did not scold.

As small children my brother and I played at being parachutists, jumping from the flat garage roof to the lawn below, aiming for the gap between the tree and the rockery. Instead of shrieks of alarm, we were rewarded with jam sandwiches when we ran out of puff.

Her relaxed attitude carried over to childbirth. During my pregnancy, having read the books purchased by my anxious husband, she slapped them shut and announced, in her usual peremptory fashion, “You don’t need books. Trust your instincts. Animals know what to do. You’ll know what to do.” Her confidence boosted mine, and baby and I managed fine once I tore up the hospital’s rigid feeding timetable.

As our son grew more adventurous, I watched heart in mouth as he thundered down the skateboard ramp, and rewarded him with ice-cream on the way home. My fear was not his reality.

Sadly, Mum died before she got to know her grandson. You could say however that her grandson got to know her. Without conscious intent, I turned into my mother, echoing her reactions and phrases.

Like others before me, it was only when I became a parent that I understood and valued everything she did. In turn, the family took—and still take—my unstinting services for granted. I graduated from spoonfeeding baby mash into my chick to spoonfeeding knowledge into him throughout his school years.

I take comfort from the fact that Mum lives on in my blood and in my bones. For one thing, I inherited her splendid disregard for housework. A house is there to be lived in, not to be admired.

I also share her practical streak – and it is precisely that practicality which lets me see where others go wrong. I can’t help it; words tumble out of my mouth before I can stop them, and I hear the echo of Mum’s diktats. “Can’t you see, it will fit if you turn it the other way round ... Give it here, I’ll do it ... Slow down, you’re driving too fast ... Stir that sauce before it goes lumpy ...”

It was uncanny how her virtues and faults came to the fore as I navigated the messy, competing demands of family life.

It’s too late for me to change. The question is, how will the next generation judge me?

← All stories

Do your best

If you do your best to be honest with yourself and others, you are helping to make The Honest Majority.

Advance Honesty